Justice S. Muralidhar criticized courts for inconsistently restricting media coverage, while occasionally offering relief to journalists.

Retired Orissa High Court Chief Justice S. Muralidhar criticized the Indian judiciary for its inconsistent handling of press freedom cases. Speaking at the BG Verghese Memorial Lecture, he highlighted the frequent use of gag orders and the uneven relief granted to journalists facing criminal prosecution or arrest. He also pointed out how investigative journalism is hindered by fear of defamation suits and threats from powerful individuals. Muralidhar also discussed the judicial response to criticism, citing instances where judges selectively used media for their own advantage while being quick to react to critiques. He stressed the importance of an independent judiciary and a free press, which are crucial for each other's survival.